Rouf E et al. 2007 "Computers in the exam room: differences in physician-patient interaction may be due to physician experience."
Reference
Rouf E, Whittle J, Lu N, et al. Computers in the exam room: differences in physician-patient interaction may be due to physician experience. J Gen Intern Med 2007;22(1):43-48.
Abstract
"BACKGROUND: The use of electronic medical records can improve the technical quality of care, but requires a computer in the exam room. This could adversely affect interpersonal aspects of care, particularly when physicians are inexperienced users of exam room computers.
OBJECTIVE: To determine whether physician experience modifies the impact of exam room computers on the physician-patient interaction.
DESIGN: Cross-sectional surveys of patients and physicians.
SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: One hundred fifty five adults seen for scheduled visits by 11 faculty internists and 12 internal medicine residents in a VA primary care clinic.
MEASUREMENTS: Physician and patient assessment of the effect of the computer on the clinical encounter.
MAIN RESULTS: Patients seeing residents, compared to those seeing faculty, were more likely to agree that the computer adversely affected the amount of time the physician spent talking to (34% vs. 15%. P=0.01). looking at (45% vs. 24%, P=0.02). and examining them (32% vs 13%. P=0.009). Moreover, they were more likely to agree that the computer made the visit feel less personal (20% vs. 5%. P=0.017). Few patients thought the computer interfered with their relationship with their physicians (8% vs. 8%). Residents were more likely than faculty to report these same adverse effects, but these differences were smaller and not statistically significant.
CONCLUSION: Patients seen by residents more often agreed that exam room computers decreased the amount of interpersonal contact. More research is needed to elucidate key tasks and behaviors that facilitate doctor-patient communication in such a setting."
OBJECTIVE: To determine whether physician experience modifies the impact of exam room computers on the physician-patient interaction.
DESIGN: Cross-sectional surveys of patients and physicians.
SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: One hundred fifty five adults seen for scheduled visits by 11 faculty internists and 12 internal medicine residents in a VA primary care clinic.
MEASUREMENTS: Physician and patient assessment of the effect of the computer on the clinical encounter.
MAIN RESULTS: Patients seeing residents, compared to those seeing faculty, were more likely to agree that the computer adversely affected the amount of time the physician spent talking to (34% vs. 15%. P=0.01). looking at (45% vs. 24%, P=0.02). and examining them (32% vs 13%. P=0.009). Moreover, they were more likely to agree that the computer made the visit feel less personal (20% vs. 5%. P=0.017). Few patients thought the computer interfered with their relationship with their physicians (8% vs. 8%). Residents were more likely than faculty to report these same adverse effects, but these differences were smaller and not statistically significant.
CONCLUSION: Patients seen by residents more often agreed that exam room computers decreased the amount of interpersonal contact. More research is needed to elucidate key tasks and behaviors that facilitate doctor-patient communication in such a setting."
Objective
To determine the impact of physician experience on the use of exam room computers and the physician-patient interaction at a Veterans Administration (VA) hospital in New York City.
Tools Used
Type Clinic
Primary care
Type Specific
Internal medicine
Size
Large
Geography
Urban
Other Information
The study took place in the Veterans Administration New York Harbor Healthcare System Primary Care Clinic
Type of Health IT
Electronic medical records (EMR)
Workflow-Related Findings
"Patients seen by residents, compared to those seeing faculty, felt the computer in the exam room adversely affected the amount of time the physician spent talking to (34% vs. 15%. P=0.01), looking at (45% vs. 24%. P=0.02), and examining them (32% vs. 13%. P=0.009).... Patients seeing faculty physicians estimated the physician spent a smaller proportion of visit time interacting with the computer than patients seeing resident physicians."
Twenty percent of patients seeing residents were more likely to agree that the computer made the visit feel less personal compared to 5 percent of patients seeing faculty.
Only about 8 percent of patients seeing both faculty and residents felt that the computer interfered with their relationship with the physician.
Study Design
Only postintervention (no control group)
Study Participants
The study participants included 12 internal medicine residents, and 11 internal medicine faculty along with 155 of their patients.