Wetterneck TB, Lapin JA, Krueger DJ, et al. "Development of a primary care physician task list to evaluate clinic visit workflow."
Reference
Wetterneck TB, Lapin JA, Krueger DJ, et al. Development of a primary care physician task list to evaluate clinic visit workflow. BMJ Qual Saf 2012 Jan;21(1):47-53.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Interventions designed to improve the delivery of primary care, including Patient-Centered Medical Homes and electronic health records, require an understanding of clinical workflow to be successfully implemented. However, there is a lack of tools to describe and study primary care physician workflow. We developed a comprehensive list of primary care physician tasks that occur during a face-to-face patient visit. METHODS: A validated list of tasks performed by primary care physicians during patient clinic visits was developed from a secondary data analysis of observation data from two studies evaluating primary care workflow. Thirty primary care physicians participated from a convenience sample of 17 internal medicine and family medicine clinics in Wisconsin and Iowa across rural and urban settings and community and academic settings. RESULTS: The final task list has 12 major tasks, 189 subtasks, and 191 total tasks. The major tasks are: Enter Room, Gather Information from Patient, Review Patient Information, Document Patient Information, Perform, Recommend / Discuss Treatment Options, Look Up, Order, Communicate, Print / Give Patient (advice, instructions), Appointment Wrap-up, and Leave Room. Additional subcodes note use of paper or EHR and the presence of a caregiver or medical student. CONCLUSIONS: The task list presented here is a tool that will help clinics study their workflows so they can plan for changes that will take place because of EHR implementation and/or transformation to a patient centered medical home.
Objective
To develop a comprehensive but generic task list of primary care physician (PCP) tasks that occur during a face-to-face patient visit, which can be used as a workflow evaluation tool by healthcare professionals and organizations. The task list would be developed by studying a wide variety of primary care practices.
Tools Used
Type Clinic
Primary care
Type Specific
Family practice and internal medicine
Size
Small and/or medium
Geography
Urban and rural
Other Information
Study 1: 15 primary care clinics in Wisconsin (14 sites participated); Study 2: 3 clinics with 16 physicians and 2 physician assistants.
Type of Health IT
Electronic health records (EHR)
Type of Health IT Functions
Not specified.
Context or other IT in place
Not all sites had EHRs in place: of 17 practice sites, 11 had EHRs.
Workflow-Related Findings
A task list was generated from observations of 50 patient-physician visits. Resulting task list consisted of 32 major physician tasks and 683 detailed subtasks that were identified as occurring at least once across all of the observations. A final task list with 12 major tasks defined by action verbs and 189 subtasks providing the object of the action for a grand total of 191 possible tasks.
Peer reviewed articles were searched and medical texts on taking a medical history and performing a physical exam in primary care were reviewed to compliment observations to develop a preliminary task list.
Study Design
Other
Study Participants
Observations of physician-patient clinic visit from 30 PCPs across 17 internal medicine and family medicine clinics in Wisconsin and Iowa across rural and urban settings and community and academic settings. Clinics were recruited via the Wisconsin Research and Education Network, the WI primary care based research network.